TS-Si is dedicated to the acceptance, medical treatment, and legal protection of individuals correcting the misalignment of their brains and their anatomical sex, while supporting their transition into society as hormonally reconstituted and surgically corrected citizens.
| TG Politicians Stick It To UK Women |
|
|
| Opinion - Guest Columns | |||
| Maggie Fox | |||
| Thursday, 28 April 2011 08:00 | |||
Manchester, UK. For far too long now a small but vociferous lobby group of transgender queer advocates have held sway in the United Kingdom. Readers, including those in the US, may ask so what?It is essential to know their basic deception: gender is a range — when we know it is not. They continue to cause more problems than they solve by trying to convince both the United Kingdom and American Governments that someone who cross dresses but retains a penis is a woman. Unfortunately for all of us, this group has had a disproportionate influence on formulating the standards of care put out by the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) on through their application in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM). Probably everyone who visits this site will find examples of their vitriolic attacks on those who disagree with their God given definitions of gender. ![]() Ms. Lynne Featherstone, the UK Minister for Equalities, issued an e-bulletin that includes a call to take an online survey so they can develop an understanding of women's issues. Subsequent e-bulletins and surveys are expected to focus on specific themes, depending on the feedback they receive. So, read the document below and take the online survey. You have until 6 May 2011. Talking points. Make whatever points you want to illustrate that women who are born transsexual simply correct their sex with the objective of integration and assimilation into society. I suggest, as a minimum, we tell them: • “Neither correcting your sex or your identity is a mental illness!” • “Transgender is NOT transsexual and grouping them together is an insult to all women”. e-bulletin. Message from Lynne Featherstone MP, Minister for Equalities. Government Equalities Office. Transgender e-bulletin No.1, April/May 2011. [ Download e-bulletin (PDF) ] Survey. Strengthening Women’s Voices in Government – a Government Equalities Office Consultation. Government Equalities Office. Online survey. [ direct link ]In my opinion, current Gender Theory is a fictitious, nasty, sociopolitical invention that denies the fundamental differences between transsexual, intersex and crossdressing. It causes far more problems than it solves by grouping everyone under Trans or Transgender.You can do something to show our rights are eroded and exploited by a group that denies our existence to further their own self interest. You can tell the UK Government it is time to face the truth. [cf. Sidebar] If you don’t think we need to act, here is a reminder of their twisted thinking taken from a standard reference available only in Gender La La Land: A Dummies Guide to Gender Theory, Chapter 1: Definitions & MeaningsIf you simply want to correct your external genitalia to match the sex of your brain it is vital that you learn all the correct terms that will be demanded of you by the psychiatrist or psychologist that will earn a huge fee for writing out a note to say you are approved for surgery.Firstly, of course, you must accept that you have an incurable mental illness that denies you the right of self determination. So here are some of the things you must memorize and repeat back over the minimum period called the real life test that is designed to make you a fully fledged transgender. You would think you’d start as either a man or a woman but Gender Theory can never be that simple: your perception of how others perceive you must be polished up to brilliant paranoia. This chapter gives the novice both the correct Gender Theory Approved (GTA) version and the Real World (RW) version that those who have not passed the real life test might inadvertently assume to be true. Study carefully, there will be a test. CisgenderGender Theory Approved (GTA): Adjective used in the context of gender issues and counseling to refer to a class of gender identities formed by a match between an individual's gender identity and the behavior or role considered appropriate for one's sex.Real World (RW): A woman that pees sitting down or a man that pees standing up. TransgenderGTA: Someone who does not identify with conventional categories but combines elements of both or moves between the two; sometimes used as a general, inclusive term, and sometimes as synonymous with or opposed to more specific terms such as transsexual or transvestite etc.RW: Someone with a penis who wears a dress. TranssexualGTA: person whose gender self image contradicts with the physical gender he/she was born with or one who has changed or is in the process of changing his/her physical sex by undergoing medical treatment such as hormone replacement therapy (HRT) and/or sex reassignment surgery. There being no contradiction between these definitions as gender is a range.RW: Someone who intends to have irreversible sex corrective surgery including removing the capacity to reproduce in the assigned birth sex. WomanGTA: The concept of being a woman is considered to have more challenges, due to society not only viewing women as a social category but also as a felt sense of self, a culturally conditioned or constructed subjective identity. The term "woman" has chronically been used as a reference to and for the female body; this usage has been viewed as controversial by feminists, in the definement of "woman".There are qualitative analyses that explore and present the representations of gender; feminists challenge the dominant ideologies concerning gender roles and sex. Social identity refers to the common identification with a collectivity or social category which creates a common culture among participants concerned. According to social identity theory, an important component of the self-concept is derived from memberships in social groups and categories; this is demonstrated by group processes and how inter-group relationships impact significantly on individuals' self perception and behaviors. The groups to which people belong will therefore provide their members with the definition of who they are and how they should behave in the social sphere. RW: A person without a penis.
|
|||
| Last Updated on Thursday, 28 April 2011 11:08 |
Add comment
TS-Si often publishes material that presents challenges and insights worthy of extended discussion. We encourage lively, open debate and ask that you show respect for others with responsible comments. This can be done with emotional maturity and intelligence. Before commenting, please thoroughly read the article and other comments, then stay on topic. Address the issues without presumptions about the author(s) or other persons.
We will remove any comment that is a personal attack or off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, libelous, mysogonist, obscene, phobic, profane, racist, or otherwise inappropriate. Removal for cause may occur without prior notice and repeat offenders may lose commenting privileges. These abuses and/or any attempt to post a solicitations and/or advertising, flood, spam, or otherwise disrupt TS-Si.org operations are subject to further sanctions.
All comments are subject to our terms of use and overall site policies, available under the About menu tab.
We will remove any comment that is a personal attack or off-topic, abusive, exceptionally incoherent, libelous, mysogonist, obscene, phobic, profane, racist, or otherwise inappropriate. Removal for cause may occur without prior notice and repeat offenders may lose commenting privileges. These abuses and/or any attempt to post a solicitations and/or advertising, flood, spam, or otherwise disrupt TS-Si.org operations are subject to further sanctions.
All comments are subject to our terms of use and overall site policies, available under the About menu tab.



Manchester, UK. For far too long now a small but vociferous lobby group of transgender queer advocates have held sway in the United Kingdom. Readers, including those in the US, may ask so what?
Theory
Maggie Fiona Fox is the human being produced by a cake shop assistant from Tredegar, Monmouthshire. She was adopted at birth and educated at Bassaleg Grammar School Newport and the Queen Mary College, University of London Nuclear Engineering Department. After a diverse career encompassing Ladies Fashions, Commercial Management, Information Technology and even Biscuit Making.
The TS-Si News Service is a collaborative effort by TS-Si.org editors, contributors, and corresponding institutions. Sources can include the cited individuals and organizations, as well as TS-Si.org staff contributions. Articles and news reports do not necessarily convey official positions of TS-Si, its partners, or affiliates. We welcome your comments. Use the form below to leave a public comment or send private correspondence via the TS-Si Contact Page. We will not divulge any personal details or place you on a mailing list without your permission.
The TS-Si News Service
and the TS-Si Research Service are collaborations of TS-Si officials, staff, contributors, and corresponding institutions. The contents do not necessarily convey official positions of TS-Si or its owners, participants, partners, or affiliates.
Comments
(just thought I'd start off the explosive reactions here)
I've seen a push in various parts of the world for a third sex category, let's call it T, so we'd have M, F, or T. A category of T might make some people happy, but for me it would be totally unacceptable, as I'm female, period, and do not consider myself in any way beig in-between M and F.
Nor do I want to be forced to use unisex bathrooms only. Once again, being female, I should be able to use the women's bathroom. To do otherwise would be to treat me as a 2nd class woman.
I'm not against the creation of a third gender marker per se, but I do think that if society sees transsexuals as just part of the transgender group, and therefore, is required to use a T marker, then I'd be very unhappy about it.
Are you going to measure the number of replies in Inches or Words??
Just askin'.
[wait for it}
Or perhaps stones.
I am cursed to take a males body to my grave.
So I am relegated to being a cross dresser/TG regardless of the fact I have been full time for quite some time now?
I would love to have a vagina and good health to pursue a new life. That dream is denied me.
Please do not call me a man.
So I should die now because my life as a woman impossible with a penis? Only my doctor and I know I have a penis. The world treats me like a woman. I am a woman. In every way save a couple ounces of ussless flesh between my legs, I am a woman.
I have some serious medical issues. I will last anouther 5-6 years.
All I was attempting to do was inject some humanity into the debate.
This is not always a black and white world.
The list includes? Never published as won't stand up to peer scientific peer review.
Myth 2. That Trans may indicate an underlying serious mental illness, a medical condition that talking can cure, thereby eliminating the need for surgery.
The list includes? Never published as won't stand up to peer scientific peer review.
Myth 3. It has to be a mental illness as I can't afford surgery and it wouldn't be funded otherwise.
A better classification outside of specialist psychiatry dominated by gay men / admirers is easy and the surgeons can set their own acceptance rules which is easy and what would happen.
In England with the best surgeon in a fantastic private hospital the cost is just £10,000 (17,000 USD) which is not a lot to pay to make a permanent irrevocable correction of a birth defect. If you can't borrow that what is your life worth?
Transgender are men with excuses whilst women find a way that's a key indicator of different brain sex by the way!
Peace, Love & Light.
ungs would cease to function and they would be unable to get them restarted.
That along with threats by her Ex to cut off contact with her only child and general constant sniping and lies by her sister and other family members finally became too much and in a fit of deep depression, she committed suicide.
Things do happen.
So anaesthetic is possible for MG patients wanting sex corrective surgery.
totw.anaesthesiologists.org/.. ./...
Your condition that means you must keep your penis is?
Come on give me a laugh!
I'm beginning to think you ARE a pretty nasty person IF you found something humorous in her committing suicide or looking for someone to give you a "laugh" out of it.
My advice to you is "go pound sand!"
It is not a valid argument for the assimilation of women who were once women born transsexual into the transgender myth.
I don't care if you refuse surgery or only want "top surgery" but the qualification for being a woman is simply not having a penis.
In England the law allows yo have a female birth certificate but requires you to become a transgender to get it. If you ask for a new birth certificate having had irrevocable sex corrective surgery you are refused one as that is not a valid criteria.
That is the crazy world of trans-theory written by lazy men for men to demean the status of women to something that only a male psychiatrist (usually gay or an admirer) can affirm.
If you think I'm being a "nasty person" by defending all women's right to say "you have a penis you are a man" then I gladly accept it.
"Trans" is a sand sculpture that the power of the sea of women will wash away.
In my own case, my medical history was a significant hurdle. I got over that, of course, but saw others who could not, daunted and overwhelmed by complex medical and financial considerations. I also saw others with even more difficult obstacles make it through.
There comes a point where human resolve reaches the breaking point.
I think Maggie should reexamine what Pamela actually said and reconsider her response.
For Pamela: one thing I have often wondered about is whether someone who falls apart when confronted with the difficulties of obtaining corrective surgery was a good candidate for surgery in the first place.
If an individual is susceptible to depression and despair, that might require attention before making major health decisions.
I am entirely sympathetic to the situation of people who cannot get the money and/or medical cooperation to achieve correction. I am far less sympathetic toward narcissistic people who make excuses and whine about their oppression -- the real subject of their narrative.
This case, as Pamela describes it, strikes me as quite different. She sounds like someone who had a tough obstacle course to run, but lacked the tools to do it.
"The term trans as in trans man, trans woman, trans community, trans people etc. is a very British term, coining in the 1960s when a well known member of parliament uttered the words;
“transgender, transsexual, transvestite – this gets so confusing – there must surely be one word we can use to refer to all”
One joker around the table suggested “transistor radios” and following that up, another wit said “that’s it: trannie”, and then the voice of reason said that might be objectionable to some ‘trans’ people, at which point the term came into being."
transequality.co.uk/.../
So, even before I can discuss the word “transsexual”, I’m immediately forced to consider the words “sex” versus “gender”. Both words have multiple meanings, in part, due to sloppy usage on multiple forms we fill out in life. However, bottom-line, the word sex can refer to one’s biological sex or the act of having or doing what one calls sex. Because of this latter definition, and the puritanical characteristics of our society, I speculate that many people end up using “gender” to refer to one’s sex, as the word “sex” makes some people uncomfortable, just as some do not like the word “transsexual”, as it has that word “sex” in it — OMG!
So, one will find some transsexuals referring to themselves as “transgender” to avoid connotations of transition having something to do with wanting to have sex. Suffice it to say, for good or ill, the words “sex” and “gender” are commonly used to mean the same thing, and therefore, are synonyms in this respect. However, the word “gender” is also used to refer to arbitrary and socially-constr ucted, sexually-dimorp hic rules and behaviors associated with being male or female. The word “sex” does not have this particular use, just as the word “gender” does refer to sexual intercourse.
Therefore, in order to make myself perfectly clear, I will use the term “sex” to refer to those innate, biologically-so urced aspects of being male or female, and the term “gender” to refer to social role and presentation of being male or female.
At birth, the identification of male or female sex is made on the basis of penis or no penis. This is such a basic reality of human existence, that doctors of our modern age (within the past 50 years or so) would and still do surgically alter intersexed babies to force them into one of the two groups — male or female. The problem with this, of course, is that the baby is too young to speak for themselves and say “I’m a boy” or “I’m a girl”.
For those without deformed or intermediate appearing genitalia, the decision is immediately made on the basis of penis/no penis, corresponding to boy/girl, which then is documented on the birth certificate.
I digressed onto this topic of birth, as it is becoming clearer through medical research that not only are the body’s primary and secondary sexual characteristics generally sexually dimorphic, but so is the brain itself, with the former being visually obvious, and the latter being not visually obvious. Now, if the body can be born with intersexed characteristics , what about the brain? Personally, I would see no reason it couldn’t also have intersexed characteristics.
Herein lies, I believe, a central truth. There are indeed, most likely, those with intersexed brains. Does that make them male or female? Genderqueer? A crossdresser?
I, for one, cannot look at someone else and make such a determination. If one is insistent upon wanting a label, I suggest they find an appropriate qualified therapist, who can assist them in applying the appropriate label.
But back to the contentious word “transsexual” — Once again, there were transsexuals in existence long before modern medical science made it possible to correct this birth defect. So, at some point transsexuals had to either find a way to live with their condition or commit suicide. The intense internal dysphoria did and does still result in significant numbers of transsexuals, as well as transgenders, committing suicide.
Historically, those, those whom would be considered transsexuals in pre-modern times (keep in mind “transsexual” is a modern term coined with the availability of surgical correction, and therefore, referring to those who did so) often did attempt whatever means possible at the time to force their bodies to match their brain sex.
Examples of this exist to this day. Desperate transsexuals cut off their penis, sometimes dying in the attempt. As I said a moment ago, the term “transsexual” came about with the availability of surgical genital correction, so obviously it is a term referring to those whose brains are cross-sexed with their bodies and seek surgical correction.
Much of the fighting over the use of the term “transsexual” seems to me to be in regards to those who self-identify as “transsexual”, but have no desire to transition. This situation is further complicated by those who for various reasons treat the words “transgender” and “transsexual” as synonyms, just as we could argue for eternity as to whether or not “sex” and “gender” mean the same thing, or why one drives on a parkway, but parks on a driveway!
This all aside, the reality is that it can and does take transsexuals varying amounts of time to come to terms with their reality and decide to transition. Personally, I believe that unless one commits suicide first, they will eventually start the process of transition and will be driven to complete this task (as much as they are able and modern medicine allows), as there brains are fully female (or male) and they want their bodies to match accordingly.
Now for one to say they are a transsexual, but they like having a penis, well, I have yet to meet a woman who wants a penis, at least not in that way — grin! Such a person might indeed have a partially cross-sexed, or intersexed, brain, and if they insist upon a label, I’d guess transgender, or genderqueer, or some other term is probably more fit than transsexual.
I say this because the argument can go both ways. “You’re not really a transsexual because you don’t have xxx!” or “You’re deluded, because I’m a transsexual and don’t need or want xxx! In fact, I’m going to work to prevent you from being able to obtain xxx!”
Now, I’ve said all I’m going to say for now on this tedious topic, which seems to get blown way out of proportion. I’m just going to hope we can get past arguing long enough to work together to help protect the rights and needs of every individual, which is what I like about the US constitution, in that it states we should all have the right to pursue happiness and live in peace with each other. I find all of this fighting tiring and boring.
I was diagnosed as a transsexual by skilled psychologists. I had no more interest in wearing that label the rest of my life than when other doctors told me I had cancer. In the former case, I transitioned and have put the label behind me, and in the latter case, I had the tumor removed. In both cases I have moved on. Life presents each of us with multiple challenges, and each of us must do what is necessary to find some amount of peace and happiness in this life.
I truly hope that the rhetoric I’ve seen can be toned down a bit, and we can instead focus upon making this world better for everyone, but then again, I’m a deluded dreamer, I guess!!! LOL"
Whole thing is a childish "trannier than thou" game that I would have hoped adults would be above.
The fantasy or fetish role where women can have a penis has dominated Gender Theory with very aggressive transgender people silencing all those who question the scientific basis by screaming transphobia and gender is a range.
Gender is at best a range of expression & perceptions but not including the right to deny physical sex correction and full integration into society.
Transsexuals never change the sex of their brain nor are they confused about it.
As a direct result three key issues remain unresolved for men & women who were born transsexual.
1 The absolute and total removal of the mental illness classification.
2 The automatic right to a corrected birth certificate with no pre-conditions if someone has had full sex corrective surgery.
3 The absolute right of a child from age 8 to obtain puberty delaying drugs prior to corrective surgery at 16 without permission from the medical profession.
Transsexuals do not deny the rights of Transgender to campaign for a third sex or gender but not at the cost of denial of corrected sex.
You might find this even more helpful
ts-si.org/.../...
RSS feed for comments to this post